Diagnosing Obamacare Website Performance Issues with APM Tools
Many Americans are looking forward to the new Healthcare website that allows them to select the health insurance best for their needs. As with any new website that has been anticipated by a lot of people, it was not a big surprise there were glitches when millions of citizens tried to use the new portal after its launch.
Now – there are many different reasons why websites that need to scale for that many users don’t deliver on the promise of good end user experience. A general “cultural” problem is that performance and scalability are pushed towards the end in favor of more functionality resulting in problems that don’t allow the end user to consume these great features. Changing this culture with the support of tools that integrate in your continuous delivery process is mandatory to avoid these types of problems. We have blogged about this in the past based on discussions we had with companies that made that transitions.
Let’s put the spotlight back on this key Obamacare website. At the time of this posting, I’m not privy to data collected from within the site’s production datacenter environment. That kind of code-level visibility would help us find the root cause of problems immediately. However, we can still learn quite a bit by using our freely available tools that analyze how web pages and third party objects are rendered within real end-user browsers. Our goal is to quickly find the top problem patterns that help us figure out why so many people are complaining.
One of my colleagues walked through different use case scenarios on healthcare.gov and sent me his AJAX Edition session files for analysis. Here is an overview that shows that most pages lack basic WPO (Web Performance Optimization) aspects:
Now let’s have a closer look and highlight the key observations from these sessions.
Observation #1: Homepage impacted by Initial HTML and 3rd Party Content
Good news is the first visual impression is good with being under 2 seconds. But – there is definitely the option to optimize overall page load by optimizing the use of 3rd party components and making sure the initial HTML page can be served faster from the web servers.
Observation #2: NO CSS and JS Merging on Registration Page
Besides not merging files they also use some non-minified versions of the jQuery plugins and use rather large and uncompressed versions of their images.
Observation #3: Server-Side issues with AJAX calls on Profile Page
The most obvious end user performance impact was seen on the My Profile page. We could see a 16.8 second server response time for an AJAX call that returned some basic user information for the logged in user. The end user has to sit and wait until that AJAX request finally completes so that the page is fully operational. The timeline shows how much impact this AJAX request really has:
What’s even more interesting is that every interaction on the MyProfile page re-sends this AJAX Request returning basically the same information again without caching it. Taking a closer look at the actual content that is returned, it seems that about 95% of the content is always the same (e.g: name, phone number, …). There is only one field in that returned JSON object that actually changes. The question is whether this can be optimized to cache that static information (Name, Phone, …) and only return the dynamic values. This would also speed up server-side processing, reduces network package size and improves end user response time:
The ToDo List in order to “Get Well”
Looking at these observations there are several points for a ToDo List in order to make the site faster and more responsive:
- Rethink the 3rd Party components. Delay loading of these components if possible to not impact initial page load time
- Merge JS and CSS files to reduce the number of roundtrips
- Compress Images to save on network bandwidth
- Optimize the server-side performance for these long running AJAX Requests
In general, it is important that you optimize your website for performance based on the anticipated load from its inception, to the website design, and all the way through the development phase and roll-out. This is not only important for application launches but anytime you have higher peak load events, which we call “Rush events”. You not only need the solutions, but the framework and step by step best practices to plan for peak events or launches. Compuware has developed best practices guides, customer stories of success and expert advice around optimization in performance in a free program called “The Compuware APM Rush Program.” Visit this site for access to the expert advice and methodologies to ensure your launch or rush event goes flawlessly.
More Things to Consider …
Those of you that know our blog are familiar with all the problem patterns we have talked about in the past. This list of problem patterns just adds to the list – but in fact – there is not a whole lot of new concepts here. It seems that we keep seeing the same problem patterns over and over again. If you are responsible for end user experience, performance or scalability of your Web, Mobile, Desktop or any type of other application that needs to deliver value to the end user have a look at our top blog posts such as Top 8 Performance Landmines, Balancing the Load or The DevOps way to Solving JVM Memory Issues.